Case Details

Filings (301) Data Requests (10)Public Comments (197) Active Party and Notification List (53) Assigned Staff (6)

Item No.	Date Filed	Description Of Filing	Filing Party	Filed By	No of Attachments	Deleted Filings
301	9/30/2024	CMP Quarterly Comprehensive SmartCare Maintenance Plan Status Report	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
300	6/28/2024	CMP Comprehensive SmartCare Maintenance Plan Quarterly Status Report - July 2024	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
299	4/1/2024	CMP_Quarterly_Comprehensive_SmartCare_Maintenance_Plan_Status_Report	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
298	1/2/2024	CMP Quarterly Comprehensive SmartCare Maintenance Plan Status Report	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
297	10/3/2023	CMP Quarterly Status Report re Comprehensive Smartcare Maintenance Plane	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
296	7/3/2023	CMP_Quarterly_Comprehensive_SmartCare_Maintenance_Plan_Status_Report	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
295	4/3/2023	CMP_Quarterly_Comprehensive_SmartCare_Maintenance_Plan_Status_Report	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
294	1/4/2023	CMP Quarterly Report re Comprehensive SmartCare Maintenance Plan	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Regulatory Administration, Debra Mills	1
293	10/3/2022	CMP Filing of Quarterly Report Regarding Customer Facing Defects and Comprehensive SmartCare Maintenance Plan	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	Hevey, Richard	2
292	8/11/2022	AMENDED ORDER	COMMISSION, MPUC	COMMISSION, MPUC	1

Per Page

1 of 31 First Prev Next Last Go To

View By Set	View By Question

DR Set ID	Set Description	Issue Date	No. of DR Questions	Propounded Upon	View Questions in Set
CMP-001	CMP's Data Request to Liberty	3/14/2019	46	THE LIBERTY CONSULTING GROUP	View Questions
CMP-002	CMP Data Request on Bench Analysis	9/6/2019	7	EXM (Advisor)	View Questions
CMP-003	CMP Data Request to Lauren Loomis	9/6/2019	17	LAUREN LOOMIS	View Questions
CMP-004	CMP Data Request to Laurel Arnold	9/12/2019	16	OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE	View Questions
CMP-005	CMP Data Request to Julie Keim	9/12/2019	3	OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE	View Questions
CMP-006	CMP Data Request to David Semon	9/12/2019	5	OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE	View Questions
CMP-007	CMP Data Request to OPA	9/12/2019	2	OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE	View Questions
EXM-002	Staff's DRs on CMP's May 8, 2019 Testimony on Metering and Billing	5/22/2019	15	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	View Questions
EXM-003	EXM-003 (Follow-up to ODR Set 3)	7/30/2019	4	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	View Questions
EXM-004	EXM-004	10/22/2019	33	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	View Questions

Posted By	Posted Date	Comments	Attachment(s)
Kathy Stevens 28 Church St Jay Maine 04239	3/29/2020	I feel as though CMP has made many errors and utilized poor tactics to repair the damage they have done in regards to their customer service as well as their lack of commitment to own up to and fix their systems. Why should we the customer be over billed and then billed for an audit for CMP's errors. This is long over due and a slap on the wrist is not working. If anything it is making the MPUC look as though they are for CMP rather than an unbiased party trying to ensure the customers are treated fairly.
Mary Fournier self 16 High Meadow Farm Road Eliot, Maine 03903 Email ID: judisprudence@comcast.net Phone No.: 207-748-0085	3/26/2020	March 26, 2020 Part of Fournier Comments My Comments on the Liberty Consulting Group costs, etc. need to be written here in the case Comment section fot now due to the fact that I cannot use Word on my computer for now. So. I will file these brief comments and follow up tomorrow with more as a Party to Docket No. 2019-00015. First, CMP should be submitting the full bill from Liberty Consulting for their so-called "forensic" audit to their Stock holders. Not one penny should be paid by CMP's rate payers for the audit. The audit was done in a sloppy fashion and was meant to benefit CMP only, which it did. It helped to drag the case on for far longer than was needed. The case should have corrected all problems which were discovered in the entire adjudicatory proceeding in both dockets: 2019-00015 and 2018-00194. Many CMP rate payers are still complaining about getting very high bills and about poor customer service. The other complaints which I have read deal with unbelievably high payment plans created by CMP, for bills that are much more likely than not fraudulently generated by faulty meters, a/k/a "smart meters" or due to the faulty relay operations of the "smart meters' mesh system. Many components make up the total impacts and operations of CMP's 'smart meter" system. The Commission must apply the laws. CMP has been fined a full $10 MILLION Penalty for very poor Service Quality Index (SQI). This is a large fine meant to impose punishment for poor quality service, very poor quality and there has certainly been imprudence involved as part, at least, of the reasons for that penalty.
Mary Fournier self 16 High Meadow Farm Road Eliot, Maine 03903 Email ID: judisprudence@comcast.net Phone No.: 207-748-0085	3/26/2020	March 26, 2020 Part of Fournier Comments My Comments on the Liberty Consulting Group costs, etc. need to be written here in the case Comment section fot now due to the fact that I cannot use Word on my computer for now. So. I will file these brief comments and follow up tomorrow with more as a Party to Docket No. 2019-00015. First, CMP should be submitting the full bill from Liberty Consulting for their so-called "forensic" audit to their Stock holders. Not one penny should be paid by CMP's rate payers for the audit. The audit was done in a sloppy fashion and was meant to benefit CMP only, which it did. It helped to drag the case on for far longer than was needed. The case should have corrected all problems which were discovered in the entire adjudicatory proceeding in both dockets: 2019-00015 and 2018-00194. Many CMP rate payers are still complaining about getting very high bills and about poor customer service. The other complaints which I have read deal with unbelievably high payment plans created by CMP, for bills that are much more likely than not fraudulently generated by faulty meters, a/k/a "smart meters" or due to the faulty relay operations of the "smart meters' mesh system. Many components make up the total impacts and operations of CMP's 'smart meter" system. The Commission must apply the laws. CMP has been fined a full $10 MILLION Penalty for very poor Service Quality Index (SQI). This is a large fine meant to impose punishment for poor quality service, very poor quality and there has certainly been imprudence involved as part, at least, of the reasons for that penalty.
Ann Roberts 160 Senott Road Email ID: mainemiss100@gmail.com Phone No.: (207) 242-6541	3/26/2020	The Liberty Report for all its cost merely shook a finger at CMP and did not expose the vast number of false usage billing that occurred and is still occurring. My personal bill shot up to two and a half times historic (30 years) usage and remained for 6 months when it all of a sudden returned to normal after six months of complaints. Nothing in my household changed. Many people are still struggling with this problem and should not now be charged for an audit that basically said nothing about the problem.
John Guy John Guy P. O. Box 242 Email ID: pappajohnguy@gmail.com Phone No.: 207-577-9167	3/26/2020	I feel that if there is any company that wants to continue to screw people it is CMP. Ratepayers, and the common individual should NOT be paying for this audit. We haire lawyers to defend us in other cases and we pay our way. CMP should be paying the entire thing.. Period
TL Scully 30 Washington St. Belfast ME 04915 ALSO: 65 Main St. & 20 Airport Rd. Belfast ME 04915 Email ID: wpmaine@myfairpoint.net Phone No.: (207) 338-9917	1/29/2020	I own 3 properties in Belfast so am in a good position to compare and contrast "smart meter" billing. At home, where energy use is the highest--washing machine, dryer, multiple electrical appliances--my bill is the lowest. It does not have a smart meter. At my apartment building (65 Main St.)--where no one lives, does laundry, washes dishes or showers--the bills have skyrocketed. I believe--even though I told CMP I didn't want smart meters on ANY of my properties--that they went ahead an installed them at 65 Main. I do not know what they look like, so have not been able to verify this, but it would explain the huge electrical bills I'm getting for a place where no one lives. We keep the heat at minimal levels to prevent pipes freezing. Before smart meters time, this generated a sizable bill in the one apartment that is heated only with electricity, but produced a much smaller bill in the apartment primarily heated with propane. Now that propane-heated apartment has a much higher bill. How does CMP explain all this? I wouldn't know, because I gave up calling them. It's difficult to reach them, almost impossible to understand their explanations, and the problems don't seem to go away. At my 3rd property, 20 Airport Rd., I felt pressured by the CMP technician who came to install a smart meter a few years ago. I told him I didn't want it; he argued with me that my reasoning didn't make sense. I said I still didn't want it. I never felt confident he honored my wishes, though, and, like I said, I don't know what they look like. My bills there might make sense. They've gone up, but we expanded our space and installed 2 heat pumps (which are supposed to bring the bill down, but due to added space I suppose it could be a wash). I don't trust CMP to be accurately billing me; I don't trust them to be honoring my wishes regarding smart meters; I'm infuriated that their customer service is so poor; and if I could opt for another supplier I'd do it in a heartbeat.
John Thurston 206 Hooper Ledge Road South Paris, ME 04281	1/28/2020	Public Comments Attached	2019-00015 Comments.pdf
Carlton Wilcox Citizen 1047 Intervale Rd. Email ID: cwilcox.maine@gmail.com Phone No.: 207-632-4985	1/24/2020	I submitted my letter with the referenced attachment on Thursday 1/23 at about 11:00 pm. I never received an email confirmation. At that time I did not know the docket number. I called Maine PUC and talked with a woman with an Asian accent who did not provide her name when asked. She told me to email my letter to maine.PUC@maine.gov. After speaking with her I searched the internet and phone media accounts that referenced the docket number. It is my understanding the comment period closed January 1/23. I submitted the document before the end of the day on 1/23. It is being submitted again due to receiving a confirmation from Maine PUC.	2020.01.23 Maine PUC CMP Billing Docket.pdf PUC Order_Approving_AMI_Technology_2010.pdf
Lori Clark 31 Ramsdell Rd. Gray, 04039 Email ID:Mylilykins@yahoo.com Phone No. :207-572-6080	1/24/2020	I have finished paying off my payment arrangement, and am still being charged on my bill for the payment arrangement when it shows there is no past due balance.
Kristin Nelson 74 Raydon Rd Ext York, ME 03909 Email ID: kln75a@gmail.com Phone No.: 603-848-7050	1/24/2020	I paid the last installment of our payment arrangement in January. My bill shows a zero balance for the payment arrangement, yet another installment was added to my account balance. A screenshot of my bill is attached. If they are making billing mistakes on such a simple matter, what else are they billing incorrectly? In addition, we installed a pellet stove but we are not seeing much difference in our bill. I think my bill may be estimated although it is not marked as such.	CMP January 2020.jpg

Per Page

1 of 20 First Prev Next Last Go To

Notification List Active Party List

Name of Person/Company	Representing Company	Mailing Address	Email/Phone/Fax
Altieri Esq., Matthew		254 Commercial Street Portland ME 04101	Email ID: maltieri@pierceatwood.com Phone Fax:
Antonuk, Michael	THE LIBERTY CONSULTING GROUP		Email ID: michael@libertyconsultinggroup.com Phone Ph: 717-421-7715 Fax:
Ardry, Nanette		103 Water Street, 3rd Floor Hallowell ME 04347	Email ID: nanette.m.ardry@maine.gov Phone Ph: 207-624-3686 Fax: Fax: 207-287-4300
Armstrong, Rose-Lynn		20 Canterbury Road Windham NH 03087	Email ID: rlarmstrong@rosetreecm.com Phone Fax:
Arnott, Kathryn	THE LIBERTY CONSULTING GROUP	32 Sparrow Drive Augusta ME 04330	Email ID: kathylwa101@gmail.com Phone Ph: 207-692-3596 Fax:
Bathgate, William S		10909 Monticello Road Pinckney MI 48169	Email ID: bill.bathgate@gmail.com Phone Ph: 256-570-5434 Fax:
Belleau, James E.	MARK LEVESQUE ET AL	10 Minot Avenue Auburn ME 04210	Email ID: jbelleau@tmbf-law.com Phone Ph: 207-784-4531 Fax: Fax: 207-784-8738
Burnes, Ian G		151 Capital Street Augusta ME 04330	Email ID: ian.burnes@efficiencymaine.com Phone Ph: 207-213-4149 Fax:
Chamberlin, Susan W		103 Water Street, 3rd Flr SHS #112 Hallowell ME 04347	Email ID: susan.w.chamberlin@maine.gov Phone Ph: 207-624-3679 Fax: Fax: 207-287-4300
Chrisos, Jon			Email ID: jdchrisos@sbgtv.com Phone Fax:

Per Page

1 of 6 First Prev Next Last Go To

Staff Name	Role
Cook, Christine	Staff Analyst
Davidson, Derek	Staff Analyst
FORTIN, ETHELYN	Support Staff
Huntington, Faith	Staff Analyst
Tannenbaum, Mitchell	Reviewer
Zeh, Sally	Staff Analyst

Per Page

1 of 1 First Prev Next Last Go To

Name of Person/Company	Representing Company	Mailing Address	Email/Phone/Fax
Antonuk, Michael	THE LIBERTY CONSULTING GROUP		Email ID: michael@libertyconsultinggroup.com Phone Ph: 717-421-7715 Fax:
Belleau, James E.	MARK LEVESQUE ET AL	10 Minot Avenue Auburn ME 04210	Email ID: jbelleau@tmbf-law.com Phone Ph: 207-784-4531 Fax: Fax: 207-784-8738
Burnes, Ian G		151 Capital Street Augusta ME 04330	Email ID: ian.burnes@efficiencymaine.com Phone Ph: 207-213-4149 Fax:
Clifford, Peter	LAUREN LOOMIS	62 Portland Road #37 Kennebunk ME 04043	Email ID: peter@cliffordclifford.com Phone Ph: 207-985-3299 Fax: Fax: 207-985-3211
Cyr, Paula Clerk	OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE	SHS 18 Augusta ME 04333	Email ID: paula.cyr@maine.gov Phone Fax:
Doucette, kathleen j		87 Maynard Dr Topsham ME 04086	Email ID: electrikathe@yahoo.com Phone Ph: 207-240-3609 Fax:
Farber, Ken	CENTRAL MAINE POWER COMPANY	1 City Center Portland Maine ME 04102	Email ID: Kenneth.farber@Avangrid.com Phone Ph: 207-838-3932 Fax:
Fournier, Mary		16 High Meadow Farm Road Eliot Eliot ME 03903	Email ID: judisprudence@comcast.net Phone Ph: 207-748-0085 Fax:
Friedman, Ed		42 Stevens Rd. Bowdoinham ME 04008	Email ID: edfomb@comcast.net Phone Ph: 207-666-3372 Fax:
Friedman, Ed		42 Stevens Rd. Bowdoinham ME 04008	Email ID: edfomb@comcast.net Phone Ph: 207-666-3372 Fax: